Navigation

RSS 2.0 New Entries Syndication Feed Atom 0.3 New Entries Syndication Feed

Show blog menu v

 

General

Use it

Documentation

Support

Sibling projects

RIFE powered

Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional

Valid CSS!

Blogs : Archives

avatar
< Products being announced ahead of time: bad idea?   MySQL and Blobs >
The music business is totally fucked up

When I recorded my last album and failed to do anything commercially with it, I realized that the music business wasn't at all about promoting creativity and catalyzing talent anymore. It is now solely a money-making machine where most bands are screwed and used to just make the big boys richer, without giving anything back to the artist.

Steve Albini, producer of Nirvana's "In Utero", has written an article that shows in detail, with numbers, how fucked up the whole music businness is. This just leaves another awful taste of disgust in my mouth. Playing occasionally in bars doesn't seem that bad after all now.

posted by Geert Bevin in Music on Aug 14, 2004 10:44 PM : 10 comments [permalink]
 

Comments

Re: The music business is totally fucked up

Great language for a title! Really makes me want to read your opinion on the important matters of life, not.

Re: The music business is totally fucked up

Actually, while the title could be a little less vulgar (I dont really care, but many others might), I do agree with your outlook.

Here is my beef. When CD's first came out, they cost about $10 to make, were not mass produced and so on. The sold for about $14 or more. Today, most bands turn out crap on CDs with a few decent songs, CD's are like $.50 to make in mass production (if that and I mean case, print, etc) and they sell for $15 to $25 a pop, depending on where you get it.

So tell me why is it if CD's are damn near free to make, we are paying MORE now? I mean, inflation aside, it is ludicrous we should pay more than about $3 a CD. It used to be the cost of making a CD you paid for. Now you are paying 90% of that into the record companies pocket. Ya'll know the musician makes next to nothing off of the CD. Their money comes from touring and if they are like, sponsors. It's tough being a musician now, almost not worth it. It's actually cheaper and better to produce your own CD master, dup it and sell it at small stores. You probably make more money that way. If you dont get signed, you may as well play local bars, sell your CD's after playing for like $5 a pop or so, and try to pick up gigs at local bars. With computer music so powerful these days, you have a LOT more people writing music too.

On that note, I don't buy music any more, I download it. Yeah, that's right. I pay for the songs I want. I also download "copies" to make sure they are worth it before buying them. It's a real shame the big 5 don't get their heads out of their collective asses and realize that selling songs for $1 a pop is MUCH more profitable down the road than trying to sell CD's for the ridiculous prices. They have lost what, 25% of their market already in the past couple years? With the hackers coming out with impossible-to-crack networks, downloading music for free will go on forever and no matter how many they try to sue, they'll just find better ways to hide it.

So, start selling CD's for $3, or give songs at about $.25 a pop or so, and a lot less downloading would probably go on.

Re: The music business is totally fucked up

Hey G,

Alright, checked out your songs. Not my specific style, but not all that bad either. Sounds good. One or two songs I felt had a little too much reverberation in them.

If you don't mind answering, what sort of equipment do you use? Is most of the music composed on computer first, then you play with a band live during recording? Or do you have a band and ya'll just make stuff up? I have always been curious how a band actually writes music, lyrics, etc. Does one guy write the lyrics, then another makes up music to it, including drum parts? Or do ya'll just keep on trying new phrases out, add music to it, etc?

I have a midi setup at home, but with Reason 2.5 software and a decent system, I can create hundreds of simultaneous tracks with all kinds of amazing sounds that's I wonder why bands even need to be around any more. :D Of course, my cup of tea is more the electronic style of music with dance, clubs, techno, etc. But I have heard a lot of electronic music similar to your style, and many other styles that to me sounds damn good given that its all done by a computer and SMPTE timings.

Look forward to a reply.

Re: The music business is totally fucked up

If you take offense to the words 'fucked up', you'd better not listen or read anything related to the music businness. Actually, imho the title is still too soft for the disgusting practices that are going on in this world.

Re: The music business is totally fucked up

Kevin, I'll reply to your posts tonight, thanks for having taken the time to write all this out.

Re: The music business is totally fucked up

The music business has never been about talent or musical catalysts. It's about business.

When a musician enters into a contract with a record company you lose the right to be creative on your own.

Re: The music business is totally fucked up

Still waiting for a reply Geert.

Jason, so sad isn't it. That is why I like writing my own music for fun. If something were to sound good, I'd see what it could do but wouldn't bet the farm on it. At least I am the creative one. With today's industry the way it is, there isn't any way I would want to sign with anyone. It is a VERY unfair industry, and the ones that work the hardest get screwed the most, as usual. Hell, I wont even go on, I will end up ranting for a week!

Re: The music business is totally fucked up

Hi Kevin, sorry about that, we took the week off to work in our house so I'm less at the computer than usual.

About the cost of the CD, you're right that they don't cost that much to make. However creating a professionally recorded one with a nice cover, inlay and printed CD takes a lot of investment to get all the material ready, the actual fabrication of the CD itself is a small percentage of the global cost.

Talking about myself, I decided a few years ago (when I recorded my album) to try to give it a go and do it 'professionally' all the way. So we find a great producer (Mike Butcher), rented a studio for a few weeks (during downtime to cut the costs), got some session musicians to take care of instruments we couldn't play, have some write special arrangements, ... The cost of this all was very high, but I was ready to pay that and I'm personally (still) very pleased with the result.

I had 1000 CDs created and sent out about 150 to the A&R guy of small record labels and majors, with only *one* response and nobody being reachable throught the phone. I did meet with the A&R guy of EMI Belgium and he basically said that my music wasn't sellable within the structure of a major but that he loved it. He only saw a sales outlet for them possible during concerts, but since I haven't gigged much since (starting your own company and buying a house takes up a lot of your time), I have sold much either.

Now back to the price, even if I sell all of the remaining CDs at $15 each, I wouldn't even come close to the money that the production cost me, so I'm not sure about their value having to be reduced to $3, imho they're worth more than that.

About the equipment that was used during Dream Like a Tree, I can't really comment since this was recorded in a professional studio and the gear they have there alone is too much to remember, let alone what was used on each song. I do remember we recorded in ProTools, but we only used it to cut up different takes and create a the best 'final' version out of the seperate parts. I know that the producer / sound engineer put a lot of effort in the selection and placement of the microphones and the (pre)amplifiers.

The creation of the songs has totally been done by me and the band was merely a bunch of professional session musicians that happened to be friends of me or of the producer. I wrote out a collection of arrangements and had some made for certain songs (like the string quartet which was recorded with real strings). Most of the drum and bass lines were fixed during a collection of rehearsal sessions before the recording.

Re: The music business is totally fucked up

Thanks for the reply. Ok, I see what you are saying, and frankly, for small bands, I would pay $15 or more for a CD. It's the mass produced big name's that sell millions and charge that much. I know when you pay $15, about $6 or so goes to the store, as their strike price has to be at least 30% lower, if not more. The record label I am sure takes the majory of the rest, and you make valid points that the total cost of making the CD can add up. I hadn't considered that.

However, having a talk with some co-workers, we all agreed that if we could buy a single song for .25, or buy a CD for $3 or so, none of us would be inclined to download the songs for free in MP3 or other form off the net. I would have no problem dropping $30 or so on songs I want and listen to. The old tape making machines that Tower Records and others had, where you select a song, and in an hour your tape (and later CD) was ready, was a fantastic idea! It's sad that they didn't stick with it. If I recall, royalties to the authors of the songs (or probably record labels) was a big problem.

I think Apple and their iPod have it right! A little too expensive, but if the big 5 would get on board with a single central site that you can look up any song, and if they have it you can buy the song for .25 and download it in uncompressed format no less, they could make a lot of money, recoup a lot of what they lose over the copying of songs on the net.

And I don't care what copy protection scheme they come up with, some young hacker with nothing better to do will figure out a way to defeat it. Unless they are going to make ALL new equipment require a hardware decryption device to play music, I can't see any way to stop what is going on. With encrypted access to sites, it will be impossible for FBI and others to figure out who is doing what.

Anyway... your CD does have good quality. Most of the songs I liked. Can you not send it to various music stores, have them put it on their counter? They usually offer a fair price I would think.

Re: The music business is totally fucked up

Hi Kevin,

I did submit my CD to all major digital distributions stores such as iTunes, Napster, Rhapsody and many others. They should all be selling the songs and the CD now. This already a lot off the price since you can buy per song and you can get the full CD for a lower price.

Add a new comment

:) ;)
=) :-)
:'( :(
:/ :D
:| :p
:o 8)
Your email address will not be displayed at anytime on any page.
Only provide your email address if you'd like updates on this entry
and it's comments by email.
Please answer this simple math question:
9 + 8 = 
 
 
  

Manage subscription

Remove email:
 

< Products being announced ahead of time: bad idea?   MySQL and Blobs >
 
 
 
Google
rifers.org web